Posted on May 13th, 2010 by Gavin M.
Where have you gone, Joe DiMaggio,
Frank Ross, Big Government:
‘The Nation’ Turns a Lonely Eye To Big Mullah Omar Scoop
Woop-woop-woop.1
Not surprisingly, the country’s oldest continuously published magazine, The Nation, is turning a jaundiced eye toward Brad Thor’s explosive scoop that the notorious Mullah Omar has been captured.
Always turning, this jaundiced and lonely eye. But let’s return to the practical for a moment. Brad Thor’s Explosive Scoop sounds like a detonation of dog waste and raisins, but if they put out an album, Pitchfork would totally review it. I’m just saying: Brad Thor doesn’t have to actually be in the band any more than Jefferson had to be in Starship, and I play drums a bit, so…
Originally an abolitionist broadsheet, The Nation has evolved into the most radical leftist publication in the U.S.; among its more notable moments was the publication in 1966 of the Cloward-Piven strategy for social destabilization.
And we all know what havoc Clowntard-Piven wreaked. Okay, he got me: I’m going to go look it up.2
The Nation isn’t even the most radical leftist publication in Barnes & Noble, but it’s certainly more ‘leftist’ than The New Republic, and to a Ross (or whatever his real name is), those are just two ways of saying the same thing. One of these days, and he’ll never know how, Ross will wake up to find the exact, fence-straddling middle of his mainstream occupied by The Weekly Standard, with Newsmax as a scrappy investigative entity daringly going after tomorrow’s headlines.
In that light, consider Jeremy Scahill’s recent screed, “(Not) Much Ado About Mullah Omar.”
I’ve been writing screeds for years and still don’t know what that word means, although I’ve long suspected in a vague way that it’s from the Norse, like ‘ski,’ ‘sky,’ and ‘skræling,’ as well as possibly ‘Scahill,’ so he got me: I’m going to go look it up.3
Also, title. The editors might supply these at The Nation, but how long would it have taken to come up with ‘Mullah it Over’ or even ‘Belly Up to Omar, Boys’? Eight seconds, that’s how long it takes to avoid a high-school-level Shakespeare pun by our measurements.
And it only takes four seconds to also avoid an Unsinkable Molly Brown pun. Think about it. No, think about it.
While Scahill might think it’s good journalism to bury the lead, we don’t. So let’s get right to it, shall we?
The lede? Oh right, what were we talking about again?
In his rush to criticize Brad Thor’s reporting that Mullah Omar has been captured, he waits until the middle of his piece before admitting:
I wouldn’t even be bothering to look into this now if I had not heard some parallel buzz about these rumors from military sources I actually trust.
But before Scahill gets to this nugget, he engages in some traditional liberal nihilism. Unable to attack the message, which he admits he has heard “parallel buzz” on, he attacks the messengers, saying:
It is a bit hard to believe that such a major development would have been leaked to a right-wing novelist with a name out of a Nordic porno, who is a regular contributor to Glenn Beck’s show, for publication on Andrew Breitbart’s web sites.
In some alternate world where ‘hearing buzz about rumors’ is the same thing as ‘reporting,’ some alternate Scahill’s ears are red now.
Even in this alternate world, it is hard to believe that such a major development as this would have been leaked to a right-wing novelist who is a regular contributor to Glenn Beck’s show, for publication on Andrew Breitbart’s web sites. The difference is that the novelist is not Brad Thor, but Jerkki Fäppalawänkkala, the Finnish author of right-wing cowboy, U-boat, and gladiator novels. The alternate Brad Thor is still named Brad Firbanks, and lacking the outlet of writing, bowls furiously on Thursday and Sunday evenings and is bitterly overinvolved in the HO-gauge model railroading community.
Scahill also conveys another telling item in support of Thor’s story:
No one is confirming anything at all, but I am told there are some pretty unenthusiastic denials making their way through the special forces world.
Really? Well, if Scahill has special forces sources,
SONG: “Special Forces Sources” sung by Ross and the Apollo Bicycles.4
and bases his reporting on them, then those SF sources must be good! Right?
I’m not even following the logical fallacies here, but apparently what happened was that Scahill dishonestly downplayed these rumors he heard, causing the rumors to gain all of Scahill’s credibility as a reporter and give it to Thor.
In fact, it would appear Thor and Scahill have very similar sources:
In fact, ‘it would appear’ is a phrase that reporters are taught to use in order to avoid the ambiguity of statements like ‘Scahill said’:
As for Thor, he has spent time with US special forces in Afghanistan–he claims they were a “black-ops team”– and may very well keep up some relationships with those men.
SONG: “Black Ops,” sung by Joe Bennett and the Sparkletones.
So are we to believe that Scahill’s military/SF sources are somehow more trustworthy than Thor’s? It would seem that Scahill reluctantly concedes that Thor’s sources are of value when, alluding to them, he says:
This would be the only way Thor has this story remotely right: If, by chance, he happens to know people on the ground who are in a very small, compartmentalized loop on this.
Aw, but let’s not let that get in the way. No one in his right mind should trust a best-selling novelist with a name out of a Nordic porno, who is a regular contributor to Glenn Beck’s show and publishes on Andrew Breitbart’s web sites.
Titlewise, our imagined summary post on this affair is now a tossup between ‘Thor Loser’ and ‘Wanknarök’ — although it really just keeps opening up, doesn’t it?
Notes:
1 Cf. recent, unexplained profusion of Simon and Garfunkel puns, cf. Lemonheads.
2 Cf.
3 Cf. ‘Scahill’ is one of many words in Irish whose utility is to identify lineages of Irish people.
4 Cf. muscle bikes.