The Next Caller Was Mark From Las Vegas

On the way into work today I listened to a discussion on the radio about nationalized health care. Owing to convention, a cross-section of retirees, stay-at-home moms and traveling sales execs called in and waited on hold to offer their attempts (e.g., “Joe Stalin would be your wife’s OB/GYN!”) at winning the host’s dulcet approval. I’ll admit I remained fairly unconvinced by their arguments until one caller said that America wasn’t ready for such a tax-draining scheme because, as he explained, he’d recently gone to a hospital emergency room and seen signs all over the place informing patients that no one would be denied health care, regardless of their current coverage or lack thereof.

So, if you’re scoring at home, the caller argued that the United States should not convert to a universal, single-payer health care system because … we’ve already got one.

hula-hoop.jpg
Above: A girl uses logic to explain her point

 

Comments: 25

 
 
 

Yeah, yeah, yeah , this is all well and good but it is not as interesting as Pammy’s calendar.

 
Leonard's Getting Larger
 

If I had Pammy’s calendar pinned up, I think moving from June 30th to July 1st would be like reaching on oasis in the Sahara (can’t….look….at his…hideous mug…any longer).

And I think Gavin has some serious f’in Photoshop material there.

 
 

Actually, this is an old Limbaugh talking point. He argued in the Hillarycare days that the US doesn’t need universal health care because you can just go to the emergency room.

Of course, that’s exactly the reason that health care in the US is so damn expensive — because so many Americans can’t afford to have regular checkups and preventive care, or even non-emergency treatment for ailments like broken limbs, infections, etc. Early detection and treatment is substantially cheaper than emergency room visits and major operations.

 
 

“…he’d recently gone to a hospital emergency room and seen signs all over the place…”

Well, if a sign says it – problem solved.

 
 

In a certain limited sense, he’s right: you can always go to an ER without ID, give a fake name and eventually get treatment, and if you squint right this does count as a universal healthcare system.

…it just happens to be the worst universal healthcare system ever devised. Aren’t conservatives supposed to be in favor of efficiency and measurable results?

 
 

Aren’t conservatives supposed to be in favor of efficiency and measurable results?

Based on the last six years, I have to answer Sadly, No!

 
 

Dammit, bubba! Beating me to the punch on that. Grr.

The “Fake Name Free ER Care” thing just smacks of that “Gun shows have the same requirements as a gun store” loophole.

 
 

<pedantic>Umm Travis… you misplaced the slash in OB/GYN… it should go between the b and the g, not between the g and the y.</pedantic>

 
 

Sure, emergency rooms will treat everyone they can in most but not all cases.

The funny thing is that even if you get treated, they will also try to bill you for as much as possible after the fact. At higher than insured rates, of course.

 
 

Whoops!. Thanks, J.A.B. I hadn’t noticed that.

 
 

“…he’d recently gone to a hospital emergency room and seen signs all over the place…”

Well, if a sign says it – problem solved.

It sure kept those long-haired freaky people from applying.

 
 

You sure that caller wasn’t George from D.C.?

He used that line in Cleveland recently:

“The immediate goal is to make sure there are more people on private insurance plans. I mean, people have access to health care in America. After all, you just go to an emergency room. The question is, will we be wise about how we pay for health care.”

 
 

“So, if you’re scoring at home, the caller argued that the United States should not convert to a universal, single-payer health care system because … we’ve already got one.”

You have to stop subjecting yourself to this crap. It can’t be healthy.

 
 

But don’t the wingnuts rant about the fact that all UR ILLLEGAL MESSICANS use our emergency rooms all the time?

 
 

People have access to four-star restaurant meals, too. After all, you just order, eat, and run like hell for the door.

 
 

That argument is also only true so far as it goes — it works okay if you need emergency care (say, you were in a car wreck or broke your leg or got shot), but if the reason you need medical care is for long-term treatment or preventive care or chronic conditions — you know, like 90% of all medical treatment consists of — you’re shit out of luck. You can’t take advantage of the no-one-will-be-turned-away deal if you’ve got diabetes or high blood pressure.

 
 

Think of the MBAs!!

If America reforms its health care system it will put tens of thousands of MBAs out of work! They’ll have to go back to digging ditches!

 
 

I’m extremely lucky to be living in a community that has a great county hospital. Of course, they’re perennially short of funds, and the facility is elderly, but they give great care, and they charge on an ability-to-pay basis. I shudder to think what things would be like if we had to rely on our two main hospitals to treat the indigent. They’d be tossing them out the door.

You know, I wish those MBAs would have to go dig ditches. I don’t consider myself a hateful person, but all the insurance company pricks in this town (and there are a lot of them, we’re an insurance company town) should all be living in refrigerator boxes down in the woods by Gray’s Lake, eating out of dumpsters, and hoping they can find a shelter that will take them in when they’re drunk on cheap popskull. And then when their livers wear out, they can just try to go get help at Iowa Methodist or Mercy….

I’m sorry. I tend to get a little excited about all that.

 
 

Umm, “popskull”??

Excuse me, ma’am. Uh, Candy?

Popskull??

That’s COOL!!

mikey

 
 

That argument is also only true so far as it goes — it works okay if you need emergency care (say, you were in a car wreck or broke your leg or got shot), but if the reason you need medical care is for long-term treatment or preventive care or chronic conditions — you know, like 90% of all medical treatment consists of — you’re shit out of luck. You can’t take advantage of the no-one-will-be-turned-away deal if you’ve got diabetes or high blood pressure.

Oh, Mister Pierce, you are such a Defeatocrat. Of course you can use the emergency room for those things!

You just don’t take your insulin because you can’t afford to buy it, or your power’s been turned off and so the insulin you had in your refrigerator turned bad on you, wait to go into diabetic shock, and voila! – emergency room treats you.

With the high blood pressure, you’ll still get care….just wait until the pressure makes you blow a vessel in your brain. Then, all the treatment you can stand is yours.

Why do y’all hate America, home of the best health care in the world?

 
 

I had a Republican use this line of attack on me 4 years ago. It’s a standard wingnut talking point. It doesn’t quite square with “brown people are stealing our health care!!1!!” but who expects logic nowadays?

The fact is that reliance on ERs because no other treatment is available to tens of millions of people has crippled the system, particularly in low-income areas (see King-Harbor Medical Center, lady dying on the floor while orderlies mopped up the blood around her edition) and has sent costs soaring that are absorbed by everyone who pays taxes and for health insurance. It’s a universal system, just the worst one you could possibly devise.

 
 

Nah, leave Gray’s Lake alone, Candy. They can just squat in the abandoned downtown condos once the housing bubble deflates.

 
 

You know, I wish those MBAs would have to go dig ditches. I don’t consider myself a hateful person, but all the insurance company pricks in this town (and there are a lot of them, we’re an insurance company town) should all be living in refrigerator boxes down in the woods by Gray’s Lake, eating out of dumpsters, and hoping they can find a shelter that will take them in when they’re drunk on cheap popskull. And then when their livers wear out, they can just try to go get help at Iowa Methodist or Mercy….

And then, one cold morning as the now-homeless insurance functionary squats behind a fallen tree, defecating desperately, he looks down to see his stool is ridden with maggots. Furthermore, it’s cold. He thinks to himself, Why is my poo cold? It just came out of my body — WAIT, what am I thinking? Who cares if it’s cold? I JUST SHIT A BUNCH OF MAGGOTS! My GOD, there are hundreds of MAGGOTS up inside me, and all over my bum-hole!

Then, he hears the bear. Growling and slashing at trees, one angry, hungry bear is coming for him — no doubt attracted by the scent of his waste. Desperately, he paws at the leaves in a pathetic attempt to bury his spoor — but it’s no good; he’s not a kitty. I can do better than this, he thinks, I’ll use my specialized MBA high-level mental-brain training!

Several seconds pass. No ideas materialize. The bear is getting closer. It feels like the flesh on his head is tightening around his skull, but that’s just a panic attack. He has to run. But he hasn’t even pulled up his pants. What to do? Pull up your pants. No, he hasn’t even wiped yet. The bear is closer. His left arm is numb — the panic attack, again, but he thinks it’s a heart attack. I need a baby aspirin, he thinks wildly, scooping up his poop and frantically pushing it into his mouth, chewing in grim determination to stop the bear attack, the heart attack, the death attack, the world attack, it’s fucking hopeless, he’s done for.

Yeah, that’s what should happen.

 
 

If America reforms its health care system it will put tens of thousands of MBAs out of work! They’ll have to go back to digging ditches!

This is the primary reason I want universal health care tomorrow.

 
 

(comments are closed)